Expert: Supreme Court Ruling in Gerrymandering Case Would Have Far-Reaching Effects

Seth McKee is an associate professor in the Department of Political Science who specializes in political parties and redistricting.

The U.S. Supreme Court announced today (June 19) that it will hear a gerrymandering case out of Wisconsin, which could affect how district lines are set nationwide.

Challengers in the Wisconsin case say the district lines were drawn unconstitutionally to benefit Republicans. The Supreme Court has said previously it is illegal to draw district lines to substantially benefit one political party over another, but such vague language has left room for debate on how much one party must benefit before its actions are ruled illegal.

Seth McKee

Seth McKee

Seth McKee is an associate professor in the Texas Tech University Department of Political Science who specializes in political parties and redistricting. He can speak about the potential impact of a possible Supreme Court ruling on redistricting rules nationwide.

Expert

Seth McKee, associate professor of political science,(806) 834-1880 or

Talking points

  • This could be a historic ruling if, in fact, the Supreme Court finally invokes a standard for declaring a partisan gerrymander unconstitutional, a move the Court has yet to take despite declaring its authority to adjudicate partisan gerrymandering in the 1986 Indiana case of Davis v. Bandemer.
  • If the Court took the very unlikely but possible step of setting a standard to overturn partisan gerrymanders, then the implications and ramifications would be far reaching since numerous states currently have partisan gerrymanders similar to Wisconsin’s.
  • Overturning these districting plans would create considerable instability as state legislators in various states – and most likely lower courts, too – would be charged with taking the step of drafting new plans, and these plans would have ripple effects as would-be and actual candidates reassess their campaign strategies under altered district boundaries.
  • Voters will be caught in the middle, with many of them being faced with potentially new and different representation because of changes to the districts they currently live in.
  • Finally, there is no question that greatly altering district boundaries makes elections more competitive, and since Republicans have been the primary benefactors of the current wave of partisan gerrymanders, clearly Democrats will disproportionally benefit from redistricting of this kind.

Find Texas Tech news, experts and story ideas at Texas Tech Today Media Resources or follow us on Twitter.


College of
Arts & Sciences

The Texas Tech University College of Arts & Sciences was founded in 1925 as one of the university’s four original colleges. 

Comprised of 15 departments, the College offers a wide variety of courses and programs in the humanities, social and behavioral sciences, mathematics and natural sciences. Students can choose from 41 bachelor’s degree programs, 34 master’s degrees and 14 doctoral programs.

With over 10,000 students (8,500 undergraduate and 1,200 graduate) enrolled, the College of Arts & Sciences is the largest college on the Texas Tech University campus.

Twitter
Facebook
Instagram
Pinterest


Department of Political Science

The Department of Political Science is in the College of Arts and Sciences.

The department offers graduate study in American politics, public administration, comparative politics, international relations and political theory.

Twitter
Facebook

Earl Survey Research Lab

The mission of the ESRL is to provide survey research services to the university community and to public sector agencies and organizations. Along with the Center for Public Service, ESRL serves as a support resource for students, faculty and administrators involved in survey and social science instruction and research.

Although we are housed in the Department of Political Science, we are capable of research in all fields including healthcare, economic development, public administration and customer satisfaction.

Twitter
Facebook